On more than one occasion, I have had a skeptical-atheist ask me ...
Isn't it unreasonable to believe in God today (in this modern world)...
And on occasion, I have had a skeptical-atheist tell me that it is unreasonable to believe in God (particularly given everything we know today from Science).
Here (below) is my response.
You may (or may not) be aware that there are significant examples of Atheist intellectuals who moved away
from Atheism as they examined the evidence for the existence of God (e.g., C.S. Lewis, and more recently Prof. Anthony
Flew who was considered by many to be the leading atheist intellectual in the world for many years)…
--
I am a wholly convinced Theist. As I sincerely examine my thoughts, my mind and my conscience,
I find that I am completely convinced of the existence of the Christian God.
If I may make a few clarifying comments in this context (see below)…
Christian "faith" is not primarily "belief"; it is "trust". It is willingness to take a risk in a relationship. It is willingness to take a risk in "trusting" what the Christian God has said.
Just like a relationship with a woman you are dating. If you are willing to take a risk, in trusting the woman, this is a possible basis for relationship.
We all know people who have been "bitten" through past bad-relationships, who lose their ability (or their willingness) to trust another person in relationship... and you may know how wearying that is, to be in a relationship with a person who is not willing to take a risk and trust you (and so you have to always keep proving yourself to her)...
I think there is something of this in the Christian relationship with God.
And, Christian “faith” is “trust” that then grows as we continue in relationship with the Christian God… “trust” which grows with continued experience with God, with continued experience with his “trustworthiness”
… just as in human relationships…
It is not unreasonable to believe that there is a God. In other words, given the evidence of the universe, it is not unreasonable to suspect that there is a Mind behind the Universe... It is not unreasonable to seriously consider Theism as a reasonable hypothesis to explain the evidence of the universe.
So, I think first there has to be a willingness on our part, to consider the possibility that there is indeed a Mind behind the Universe.
Proposition #1a: We first have to be willing to accept the proposition that there is a God (a Mind behind this universe).
This does not mean that we switch off our brains. It just means that we are willing to accept the proposition (if at first, provisionally, or tentatively).
I find that it truly does NOT take switching off of our brains to accept this proposition, that there is a Mind behind our Universe (see points below).
I truly intellectually think that there is evidence that points to (or at worst, is consistent with) there being a Mind behind the Universe:
Thinking through some of these areas that I have mentioned above, I found (over a period of time) the atheist explanations I was presented with (for so much of what is “real” in our universe) to be shallow and trite and almost solipsistically reductionistic… and I found atheist explanations for most things that are meaningful and beautiful in life to be near-solipsistic in nature…
… to the extent that I finally concluded that I was not able to intellectually be an atheist…
Proposition #1b: We have to be willing (at least tentatively) to accept the proposition that the Christian God exists.
E.g., given the amount of care taken to design our universe (assuming some of the points I made above, depth of Anthropic coincidences, Aesthetic coincidences, care taken in design of humans for beauty, science, math, relationship with God etc) it is not unreasonable to accept the proposition that the Mind behind the universe is one who cares, who is personally involved with the universe, and who would be interested in being involved with human beings etc.
Proposition #2: We have to be willing (at least tentatively) to accept the statement of the Christian God that he will reveal himself to those who seek him with sincerity, humility and perseverance.
Consistent with the comments above (presented with proposition #1b).
Our Response: Seek God with perseverance.
Action based on the propositions: Then, we act on these propositions, by seeking God with sincerity, humility and perseverance… And he says that he WILL reveal himself to us.
And this is what happened in my life (and in the lives of many Christians I have met and otherwise come across).
Question from Skeptic Skeptic =>
Isn't it unreasonable to believe in God today (particularly given everything we know today from Science).
A Christian Response
Christian Faith vs Belief
Theism is not unreasonable
Proposition #1a: God exists.
Proposition #1b: The Christian God exists.
Proposition #2: The Christian God reveals himself to those who diligently seek him.